Albi | Father sentenced to 10 years for raping his adopted son
"From a father, you become a lover, because he asks you to? It’s difficult to imagine that…"
After long hours of reflection, the Tarn Assize Court sentenced this former educator to 10 years of criminal imprisonment. His adopted son, met in a home, accused him of rape.
Daniel* told the court:
“I adopted Pierre* with the aim of being a dad”
Failing that, he has instead become a drinking buddy for the young boy he adopts.
And even a torturer, Pierre told the courtroom.
At 34, the young man decided to file a complaint against his adoptive father.
He accuses the latter of multiple rapes, committed over a very long period, between his 13 and 25 years old.
Daniel always denied it, speaking of “relations between consenting adults” when Pierre was an adult.
The adoptive father swears:
“I never assaulted him, kidnapped him, forced him or anything. He was the one who asked me, he wanted to have a homosexual relationship, to know what it was”
The president of the court almost chokes:
“From a father, you become a lover, because he asks you to? It’s difficult to imagine that…”
The other doesn't really know what to answer:*
“At that time, I drank a lot. It's not an excuse, but I mixed everything up, the role of father, of friend... I lost control.”.
“I was in love with him”
Daniel was an educator in a youth home.
Pierre was a resident there.
The adult takes the kid under his wing, protects him from others who make him a pain.
Very quickly, the child and his educator become very close.
Daniel begins an adoption procedure and becomes a trusted third party for the teenager, whom he can take home on weekends.
It was at this time that the rapes began.
To continue into adulthood.
Daniel declares in court:
“I was in love with him, but our relationship only lasted a year, between the ages of 19 and 20, that’s all. As for the rest, Pierre lies”
Me David Cucullières defends the plaintiff.
He tells this “fairy tale” for a child abandoned at a very young age, who finds a father in Daniel.
He then talks about the years of ordeal, the rapes, until meeting Sophie*, who manages to extricate him from this toxic “father”.
They have a child together, which is one of the reasons which pushed him to file a complaint so many years after the events against this adoptive father, who was never really one.
“This is not the court of morality”
The attorney general explains to the jurors:
“75 % rape investigations are closed without further action. Because it is often word against word, and the complaints are generally filed years after the facts. It is therefore difficult to have proof. And in these cases, it is the sacrosanct principle of the presumption of innocence which must take precedence”
But in this case, are we in a classic case of word against word?
No, he says, and he lists the elements which, for him, overwhelm the accused.
He is asking for 12 years of criminal imprisonment.
Me Raynaud de Lage for the defense, insists:
“This is not the court of morality. Yes, my client was a bad father, a pitiful educator. But that is not the question. Do you have objective reasons to say today that he is guilty, 24 years after the events? The answer is no”
After a long reflection and in the middle of the evening, the jury returned to deliver its verdict.
Daniel is guilty of raping his adopted son.
He was sentenced to 10 years of criminal imprisonment.
*The first name has been changed